Showing posts with label girths. Show all posts
Showing posts with label girths. Show all posts

November 30, 2021

Product Review: Stubben Equi-Soft Girth

It was abject curiosity that caused me to buy a Stubben Equi-Soft girth in September. Jan had raved about hers, and I wondered what Connor would think about elastic in his Dressage girth. From the manufacturer:

The Equi-Soft girth, when properly adjusted, effectively deals with the constriction by giving in all directions and markedly reducing the tension.  This frees the underlying musculature, allows better circulation, and decreases the restriction of motion of the gut.  As respiration is enhanced and the horse experiences less discomfort, pulse rate has been shown to be reduced during exercise.  Since the muscles are less restricted, lateral flexibility is enhanced as well as the horse’s ability to employ the external obliques, serratus and other abdominal muscles necessary to support the topline.  This is manifested in greater extension of the foreleg and more active employment of the hind quarters.

But it arrived the day I dropped him off for full training, and I wasn't going to just leave him at the trainer's with a brand new girth, so I waited until I got the chance to ride him on my own in it once in early November before feeling confident enough to ask CGP to try it.


Then I got a call from her one night, "OMG congratulations on your new saddle, Connor goes AMAZING in it, like, wow! So much lift through his shoulders!"

I was super confused. Unless Kate had dropped my new saddle off at CGP's without telling me it was finished, CGP was definitely still riding in the loaner Patrick.

"New...saddle?" I said.

"Yeah!" she said, "You know, it's got serge."

"Is it brown or black?" I asked, and she said black. "Yeah that's still the loaner, the only thing I've changed this week is that's a new girth I'm trying."

"Wow!" she said, "Well he loves it, huge change!"

(Now, if you're wondering how she could be so oblivious about tack, remember that she has 6 days a week of 10-15 lessons and training rides per day, and in order to do that much volume, she's not the one tacking the horses up. Also, on a dachshund like Connor, she'd have to be pretty motivated to get under him and look at the girth. So when he felt that different under saddle, she thought something big must have changed and just assumed it was the saddle.)

It's hard to say what he loves about this girth. It may be the enormous amount of elastic in the center.


It could be that the straps actually float above the horse's sides where there is no pad underneath them.

It's hard to see when he's so fuzzy, but I'm not lifting the girth away from his side here, there's a finger-width gap here that gradually gets smaller as you go up toward the buckle.

It could be the way it ergonomically hugs his sternum.

Real talk: using dirty girths in product review photos because it was cold and I was rushing (but I did clean it after!)

It could simply be the sizing, as I went with a 24" because it was the smallest size Smartpak had, and I wanted to be able to easily return it if he didn't like it. It gets the buckles far above his elbow.

This is on one of my longest saddle pads too, the BoT with the quarter sheet visible above it here. The buckles won't even come close to the flap on my actual Dressage saddle, whenever it arrives.


But I honestly don't care, because if he loves it that much, I'm not going to ask him why! 

So the horse loves it, what about the human? Some notes, from me:

  • It has so much elastic, you're not supposed to crank it down as tightly as a normal girth. You're supposed to tighten it just tight enough to keep the saddle stable and no further. This is a little anxiety-inducing for some people (but not me, I belong to Girth Undertighteners Anonymous)
  • It has interchangeable liners (leather, lambskin or neoprene) that Velcro onto the top part of the girth.
  • It's a pain in the freaking butt to clean, especially after the Prolite, whose care instructions are "drunk in a bucket after rides". Getting underneath all those elastic pieces...ugh.
  • A friend of mine reports that she loves the Dressage version, but the jump version caused her saddle to slide back on XC (prelim/training), which makes sense since you can't crank it down super hard.

Bottom line: It's a cleaning nightmare and I'm keeping it, and that should tell you all you need to know about how much of a difference this girth made for Connor. Connor absolutely loves it.

What: Stubben Equi-Soft Girth

Colors: Black, brown

Sizes: 18" to 56"

Options: Lambskin, leather or neoprene liners available

Price: Varies depending on options selected. I paid $297 at Smartpak, which has somewhat limited options available. Full range of options are available on Stubben's website.

May 3, 2017

A Long, Circular Story about Girths and Being a Responsible Blogger

This is a long, circular story about blogging, girths, and why I completely failed at sizing them for Connor.

A long time ago, I had a..20"? 22"? Total Saddle Fit Dressage girth:


Which was fine, but I thought it was a little big.  It came up higher than I thought it should on Connor's sides.


And the World's Longest Billets on the Thorowgood I owned back then stuck out by a solid 6".

So I sold it to get something shorter and ended up with an 18" Total Saddle Fit StretchTec Shoulder Relief Girth:


Which I was moderately happy with, even if cleaning it drove me CRAZY.  You just cannot keep hair and dirt from getting in between the Velcro "halves".  It was always dirty.

Then a few weeks ago, when Connor's summer coat was coming in, I noticed white patches forming where the two "halves" of the girth must have rubbed Connor, with the velcro in between them.  I had no idea this was even happening, there were no rubs or damage to his winter coat, but we'd had that girth for months, so it had been a while, poor pony.

White spot by girth visible in this "Hey is my horse downhill?" photo I probably sent JenJ.  The white spot has since faded, so I caught it in time before it completely killed the pigmentation and became an acquired leukoderma.

I was immediately very mad at this "gimmicky" girth that hurt my horse, and was so irrationally frustrated with anatomic girths in general, I bought a contoured Lettia Click girth as an impulse buy and sold the TSF.  And came this close to writing a post about how terribly designed the TSF StretchTec girth was.  But I'm glad I didn't...

Lettia Click Girth shown.  I loved the Click mechanism.

In the process of my remote saddle fitting experience with Ann of Equestrian Imports, she pointed out that the straight Lettia girth was all up in Connor's business behind his elbow, which was pulling the saddle forward of where it should be.  She told me to move the saddle back and put a hands width of space between his elbow and the girth, which I did, but...


Both saddle and girth would always slide forward to the original location very shortly into my rides.

Ann suggested a Total Saddle Fit girth (of course she did) but in 24".  When I protested and said that must be too big, she said "Absolutely not, if it's any shorter the contours will be in the wrong places and rub him."

Immediately, I thought "Oh.  My God.  I am an idiot.  THAT'S why the StretchTec girth rubbed Connor.  It wasn't the girth's fault at all.  And I'm really glad I didn't write that scathing blog post now."

So, because Ann sells them, and because I knew some karma just came full circle, I ended up with another classic TSF girth.  This time in a 24" size.  And the saddle and girth both stayed where I put them, where Ann recommended them, through the entire ride:

Taken after a ride.

Compare to the Lettia girth photos above.  So much more freedom behind the elbow for him

There are a few takeaways here:
- Sizing anatomic girths properly REALLY matters.  And the length of the girth and whether it keeps your saddle on the horse is only one small part of that sizing.

- It's important to do your due diligence before blasting a product on this very public platform.  I am so glad I didn't write what was on my mind when I thought bad design was the reason for Connor's rubs.  We don't owe anything to the manufacturers, and should feel free to state our opinions, but man, my opinion would have been dead wrong.  And the internet is forever.

- Connor definitely needs an anatomic girth.  No question.

- I could have saved myself a lot of buying and selling if I had just thought a little more critically about how the girths fit him.


And with that...we are REALLY done shopping for saddles and girths now!