November 19, 2019

Saddle Fitting #6: Stubben, and Getting Cozy with the USEF Rulebook

Brand: Stubben
Cost for Fitting: $150
Number of Saddles Tried at the Fitting: 4
Number of Saddles Trialed: 0

Two different people messaged me on Facebook to ask how the Stubben fitting went, which reminded me that I never wrote about it!  Goes to show you how much attention y'all are paying to these saddle fitting posts, you remember what I tried better than I do.  To be fair, I did leave for Canada like thirty seconds after the Stubben fitting, so it got pushed out of my brain rather quickly.


It's a shame I forgot because Stubben was one of my more positive fittings.  This rep has been fitting saddles for 5+ years now, first with County (Ohio and I think Ketucky) and now with Stubben, where she has Indiana for the first time.  She made the brand jump because she was so impressed with "new Stubben". 

She also reps Bombers bits, and did fittings for those with my trainer and a barnmate while she was here, which knocked a bit off my fitting fee.  Please give her a call if you're into Stubben or Bombers.  She's new to the Indiana market as of September, and while she's not 9 years of education amazing, she's still one of the better fitters I worked with.



I ended up trying three models and seeing four (wrote the 1894 off on sight for looking too much like the CWD).  The first one, above, is their most bare bones model.  Even customized it'll come in under $3k.  It was fine - nothing special.

The last one I tried, and the only other one I have photos of, was fascinating.  It's a Stubben Aramis with a 17.5" seat...and a 12" flap, as measured from the bottom of the stirrup bar.  The literal shortest Dressage flap I've ever seen in my life. By like, a LOT.

Compare the same saddle pad with the Aramis...

...and the CWD, which by the way, IS a short flap!  Pro tip: use a pad you don't care about for fittings with new saddles so that if they bleed all over it, you don't cry.

I was absolutely enamored with that flap, with the feeling of feeling horse under my calf and not leather.  Literally 20 minutes after I sat in the Aramis, I sat in the flapless for the first time, and it struck me how similar the two saddles felt.  You don't notice the lack of flap in the flapless, except for the feel of horse under your calf, and the Aramis with the tiny flap felt largely the same.  The only difference is the way it felt under my thigh.

I've asked several fitters since then what the ideal flap length is, and they all say the flap should come lower on my leg than I've come to realize I prefer it.  No one has explained why that is, though. Maybe it has to do with sweat.  Am I allowed to like a ridiculously short flap?  Am I just overcompensating for the fact that I'm used to Dressage saddle flaps hitting my ankle bone?

The fitter pulled a block off of a jump saddle in order to meet my preferences, and I loved it.
The Aramis is a solid #3 for me.  That flap was delicious, but the rest of the saddle didn't knock my socks off.  This demo was way too narrow for Connor in the front, which, fine, it's a demo, but this is a brand that historically I haven't been able to get to fit him at all, so I was perhaps judging it more harshly than others when he didn't go well in it.

I did have one important takeaway from this fitting: I looked up the USDF/USEF rules on minimum flap length, and found that there are none.  Specifically, "An English type saddle with flaps and stirrups is compulsory for all tests and classes other than FEI tests..." is all it says, until you get to FEI, when you must have "long, near-vertical flaps".

Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm.  I tucked that information away in my brain for future use.

Short List: Stubben Aramis (Really) Short Flap
Likes
  • That 12" flap!
  • The tiny little block that just hinted to my thigh that it needed to stay still
  • The leather and comfort - Stubben has come a long way
  • The fitter, who has purple hair (relevant I know) and is genuinely good at her job.  She definitely is one that lost money, driving 2.5 hours one way to get to me (I'm so sorry but thank you!)
  • Velcro blocks, please and thank you
Dislikes
  • Connor didn't go well in it, because the demo didn't fit, but even still that's hard to get past
  • Just didn't knock my socks off 

15 comments:

  1. I'm glad you had a great experience with her! She is a friend of a friend, and in my opinion, one of the better saddle fitters in the area. I really like my Stubben Dressage saddle (despite trying to sell it currently). The hinged and minimal blocks on the genesis made a huge difference on my... very round mare. haha. I had been eyeing the Aramis, so maybe in the future. ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm so glad! I'm not sure if it was Aramis I loved or just the flap, but it was definitely a nice saddle, and I wouldn't hesitate to use the fitter again in the future.

      Delete
  2. Oh man, the first time I sat in a flap that short it was 100% life changing. My Black Country is a 13" flap and it's the first time I've ever felt like I had a fully effective leg in a dressage saddle. I wonder why we're "supposed" to have longer flaps... maybe some rule of thumb created by someone 6'6" with long legs haha.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm sure there's a very good reason for it, but as I'm learning with this saddle search, you like what you like.

      Delete
  3. I owned a Stubben Tristan way back in the day.I quite liked it. That first saddle looks far too big for Connor. I like the look of the second one.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yeah you're spot on with the first one, it was too big for both of us. I think that was maybe the most challenging part of this fitting, this fitter didn't travel with a trailer and had a limited amount of demos with her, although she did make an effort to discuss my preferences with me ahead of time and bring what she thought was most likely to fit.

      Delete
  4. I love my Stubben and feel they are a good option for short wide horses (Ahem Remus) BUT I get it it has to fit both you and Connor to make it work. Glad the fitting was okay though!! I want a new Stubben down the road (a bit bigger my rear end!) and hope to get it before I am too old to ride;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You really don't see many of them in Indiana, it's funny how pseudo-regional these things get. I hope you get one someday, they're very nice saddles!

      Delete
  5. I’m a dork... I was worried Stubben had gone very badly and was worried that’s why the post hadn’t shown up yet. I’m glad it wasn’t an utter disaster! I actually just bought myself an Aramis, and while I’m much rounder and taller than you are, I really like that it lets me have more bend in my knee than almost any other saddle I tried. That short flap is so short! Would love to have seen you in it, but I’m sure it was frustrating to not be in the right tree size at the same time. Did the fitter suggest a size for Connor? I’m shocked that a 29 fits my horses really well when I was originally betting I’d need a 31 or even an XW.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. How cool! I really did like the Aramis, if the demo had been sized a bit better for him things might have been different. I want to say the demo was a 28 and she wanted him in a 31 or 32! It wasn't even in the ballpark, so I didn't do too much in it. Glad you love yours!

      Delete
    2. a 29 also fits my guy a very wide load QH so i was shocked too.....I thought I would need a 32!!

      Delete
  6. I'm a shorty (5 ft) and have a Master Saddlery saddle with a 13 inch flap. To me it makes such a huge difference actually having horse under my calf instead of saddle! I don't think I could ever go back to a standard flap.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Fellow 5 ft riders unite! Maybe that's a thing.

      Delete
  7. I bet the FEI changes that flap rule in the future as these flapless saddles gain popularity. I'm guessing they just plain didn't exist when they made that rule

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hope that's all it is. It's strange to me that treeless is okay but flapless isn't.

      Delete